CUSTOMERS.COM® RESEARCH FROM THE PATRICIA SEYBOLD GROUP
Customer Service KM Evaluation Framework
How to Evaluate Knowledge Management-Based Solutions
By Mitchell I. Kramer, July 10, 2008
NETTING IT OUT
Your customers want answers to questions about your business, your policies,
and your products and services. They also want solutions to the problems
that they have with your products and services. Your agents want those answers
and solutions when your customers seek assisted-service.
Knowledge management-based customer service products can help you deliver answers
and solutions to your customers and agents through your implementation of
their content management and search facilities.
We’ve developed a framework for evaluating knowledge management-based
customer service products. The framework has these
top-level criteria:
•
Cross-channel cross-lifecycle support
•
Knowledge management
•
User interface
•
Search
•
Escalation
•
Analytic functionality
•
Architecture
•
Product viability
•
Company viability
In this report, we describe these evaluation criteria in detail. In future
reports, we will offer our framework-based evaluations of specific products
and services.
CUSTOMER SERVICE TO ANSWER QUESTIONS AND RESOLVE PROBLEMS
This report presents our evaluation framework for customer service products
that help customers get answers to their questions about your organization,
your policies, and your products and services as well as to diagnose and
resolve problems with your products and services. These customer service
products are known as knowledge management products because they combine
content management and search technologies to build customer service applications
that create “knowledge” that answers your customers’ questions.
The framework specifies and describes the criteria that we use and that we
recommend you use for evaluating, comparing, and selecting these knowledge
management-based customer service products and services.
CUSTOMERS WANT CROSS-CHANNEL, CROSS-LIFECYCLE HELP
Before we get into the details of the evaluation framework, let’s take
a step back and put these knowledge management-based customer service products
in context—the context of cross-channel, cross-lifecycle customer service.
We’ve been writing for a while about it. Here’s what we mean:
•
Customers want your help on every channel through which they interact with
you—the Web and email for service, your contact center, physical locations
(e.g., stores or walk-in centers), and your field service force for assisted
service.
•
Customers want and need your help at every phase of their lifecycles, through
every interaction and iteration within the lifecycle phases of plan, explore,
select, buy, use, maintain, and renew.
Cross-Lifecycle Customer Service

© 2008 Patricia Seybold
Group Inc.
Illustration 1. This illustration shows the phases of the customer service
lifecycle around the core of (customer) support and the focus of the customer,
represented by the proxy of your customer information.
Cross-Channel Customer Service
Your customers do business with you through mechanisms that we call channels.
Channels link your customers to your customer service agents and your customer
service systems. Channels are the technologies and the personnel through
which your customers interact with you—the Web, email, kiosks, and
contact centers, store personnel, field personnel, and call center personnel.
Channels support either self-service or assisted-service interactions. Self-service
interactions occur when customers interact with your customer service systems.
Self-service channels are automated. They typically have high implementation
costs but very low costs to serve. The Web is a key self-service channel.
It can support the broadest range of types of customer interactions.
Assisted-service interactions occur when customers interact with your customer
service personnel, who, in turn, interact with your customer service systems
on behalf if your customers. Assisted-service channels are manual. Contact
centers, stores, and field personnel are the key assisted-service channels.
They have high implementation costs and high costs to serve, although you
can implement some of them, such as field sales and support, quite quickly.
CONSISTENT CROSS-CHANNEL CUSTOMER SERVICE. We’ve discussed the need to
deliver a consistent cross-channel customer experience many times. Fundamental
requirements are a consistent view of your customers and a consistent context
for the business that they want to do with you. For customer service, consistency
is your ability to deliver the same answers to customers’ questions and
the same resolutions to customers’ problems independently of the channel
through which they choose to interact with you.
Cross-Lifecycle Customer Service
Your customers’ interactions with you traverse the phases of a lifecycle,
from the first step of the first piece of business that they do with you through
the time when they stop buying and using your products and services. Between
those points, customers perform various activities that we can associate with
phases of a lifecycle. These lifecycle phases are:
•
Plan
•
Explore
•
Select
•
Buy
•
Use
•
Manage/maintain
•
Renew/replenish
Any customer can be simultaneously in multiple phases of the life cycle. For
example, a customer can be in the process of exploring offers at the same
time that the customer is fixing problems with products already purchased
and waiting for a PO to be cut to renew the customer’s service agreement.
You want your customers to be constantly active in the select and buy phases.
In Table A, we list examples of the activities in each of these phases. In
Illustration 1 we show these phases around the core customer and the cross-channel,
cross-lifecycle customer service systems that help the customer do business
with you across channels and activities.
Customers Need Your Help to…
Please download the PDF to see the table.
Table A. Customer lifecycle phases and examples
of activities within each phase are presented in this table.
Also, while these phases typically occur in sequence as a natural
order of doing business, it’s also common that customers’ behavior doesn’t
always follow this order. Customers who need help using your product,
for example, may hop back in the lifecycle to select and buy a complementary
product. Customers who are exploring possible solutions may test the
facilities
you offer for product maintenance before they buy.
While customers are ultimately in control, it’s also important for you
to try to influence your customers’ behavior. For example, once a customer
purchases and deploys one of your products, the customer will likely perform
the activities of the use and maintain phases for some period of time. You’d
like the customer to make additional purchases. So you might make marketing
offers to the customer that will drive the customer back into the select and
buy phases.
Whether the phases are followed in sequence or whether customers act less predictably,
customers need service for every activity of every phase of their lifecycles.
If you want to build long-term, profitable relationships with your customers,
then you must create a cross-lifecycle customer experience that delivers
excellent service at every phase and every activity of the lifecycle.
Practical Customer Service
Cross-channel, cross-lifecycle customer service is absolutely essential for
strong and profitable customer relationships. However, in practice, delivering
a customer service experience with the breadth and depth to support every
channel and the entire lifecycle of your customer relationships is quite
difficult. There are two reasons for this difficulty:
This report continues...
|